The last rent paid should be the starting point for calculating compensation
When a tenancy is lawfully terminated, the tenant is obliged to surrender possession of the property, provided no other right of occupation exists. In practice, it is not uncommon for a former tenant to remain in possession without any legal entitlement, thereby becoming an unlawful occupier and trespasser.
This recurring phenomenon creates serious difficulties for property owners, who are deprived of possession and the ability to make use of their property.
Furthermore, in order to claim compensation, they may need to obtain a property valuation report, even though they already possess a recent tenancy agreement specifying a rent that was actually being paid.
They thus incur additional expenses while already suffering the consequences of unlawful occupation.
The need to address this problem is not merely theoretical. Every month of delay may mean a lost opportunity to utilise the property, while the owner’s obligations continue.
The distinction is not merely one of terminology. Following the lawful termination of a tenancy, the amount claimed for occupation without legal entitlement is no longer contractual rent but damages arising from a civil wrong.
The amount is assessed by reference to the property’s objective market rental value. Why, however, should the owner be required to incur the expense of a fresh valuation when the same parties had recently agreed upon and implemented a specific monthly rent?
The issue concerns houses, apartments and commercial premises, where delays in recovering possession may continue for months or even years.
Case law and the burden of proof
Cypriot case law treats trespass as a civil wrong giving rise to a cause of action without the need to prove specific financial loss.
Compensation does not depend on whether the owner had secured a new tenant or was in a position to use the property personally. The relevant criterion is the market rental value of the use of which the owner has been deprived.
Establishing the right to compensation, however, is one matter; proving the amount to be awarded is another.
The judgment in Adrian Holdings Ltd v. Republic (1998) 1 C.L.R. 1836 highlights this distinction.
Trespass is actionable without proof of special damage, but insufficient evidence substantiating the amount claimed may result in an award of nominal damages only.
In Papadopoulou and Others v. Municipality of Paralimni, Civil Appeal No. 94/2016, 11 February 2025, the Supreme Court examined comparative valuations and assessed the suitability of the properties used to determine rental value.
These judgments demonstrate the importance of reliable evidence in assessing compensation.
The actual cost to the property owner
In practice, where market rental value is disputed, expert evidence from a property valuer often becomes necessary.
Without sufficient proof of the amount of damages, the owner risks receiving only a nominal award, despite the established unlawful interference with the property.
A valuation is useful where the property has particular characteristics or market conditions have changed.
Nevertheless, it is unreasonable to disregard, as a starting point, the last rent actually paid under a valid tenancy agreement.
For example, if a shop was let at €1.500 per month and the former tenant continues to occupy it without legal entitlement, the owner may need additional valuation evidence to claim an equivalent monthly amount in damages.
The previous rent does not necessarily correspond to the current market rental value. It nevertheless constitutes evidence of an actual transaction between the same parties and should not be disregarded in the initial assessment.
After all, its payment reflects not a hypothetical expectation on the owner’s part, but the value that the contracting parties themselves placed on the use of the property.
A legislative solution allowing rebuttal
The state could introduce legislation amending Section 43 of the Civil Wrongs Law, Cap. 148.
Where unlawful occupation follows the lawful termination of a tenancy, the last rent actually paid should be presumed to represent the market rental value at the date of termination, unless evidence establishes otherwise.
The owner would be entitled to prove a higher value, while the former tenant could establish a lower one.
In cases of prolonged occupation, subsequent changes in market conditions would also be taken into account.
Such a presumption would neither predetermine the lawfulness of the termination nor affect any tenancy protected by law. It would simply establish an evidential starting point based on an already known and verifiable fact.
The state should consider this targeted legislative intervention and submit an appropriate bill to the House of Representatives.
The proposal does not seek to dispense with proof of market rental value, but rather to prevent property owners from unnecessarily bearing valuation expenses where there is recent evidence of rent actually paid.
A rebuttable presumption would provide a reasonable starting point, reduce costs and litigation, and preserve the right of either party to establish a different rental value.
Click here to change your cookie preferences